Malfoid Changes
What happens to the story of Harry Potter if you changed Draco Malfoy into a girl?
That depends on what kind of character Draconia Malfoy is.
If Draconia Malfoy is just Draco in a skirt, the story will be largely unchanged. Some things will be worse and maybe some better. Harry and Draconia will probably hate each other even more than in canon. Harry might not even regret that nasty curse he hit her with since she deserves it. Yeah, the story would likely actually be a bit darker. Imagine if Harry was betrayed in the Malfoy manor and killed THEN rather than latter, because he and Draconia had an even WORSE relationship than he and Draco did…
If Draconia Malfoy is a very sweet girl who walks up to Harry Potter day one on the Hogwarts Express and really seeks to be friends, rather than insulting Ron and Hermione, that whole story ends up entirely different. All the times Draco and Harry go out of their way to hurt the other goes away, and that changes numerous very key events in the story. Multiple key elements that lead to the return of Voldy Moldy straight up don’t happen. One of the revolving story lines of the books is that Harry and Draco’s antagonism towards each other as Alpha Males who each want to prove they are better than the other really does open up the door to Voldy Moldy’s return. And Draco’s growing understanding that maybe Harry wasn’t as bad as he thought is what twists some events in Harry’s favor at certain key elements. If the early events never happened at all because Draconia is just a nice girl who likes Harry, a LOT of the story gets completely replaced.
Most people who write fan fiction about Draconia Malfoy generally write her as somewhere in the Tsundere spectrum. That is an anime term for someone who is harsh or cold on the outside that covers a truly caring person underneath. They often are mean to their love interest, even as they are falling in love with them. During the early books, when they are still children, there’s not going to be an awful lot of change. But by book four, when the Yule Ball happens, that is changing. The students of Harry’s year are no longer 11 or 12 year old children. They are 14 and 15 year old young adults who now realize that boys and girls are no longer icky but can be awful nice if one can figure them out. It is in book four that the various romances of the books get their first glimpses and start tumbling around the pages through to book 7. And those romances scatter the story. A Draconia Malfoy that is falling for Harry and a Harry that is falling for Draconia would absolutely scatter the story. Some things could end the same. Others would not. One story element that would absolutely NEVER happen the way it did in the books is when Harry uses an unknown curse on Draco and nearly slices the boy apart. As Draco, Harry care doesn’t about him. Draco is a rude, nasty, boy who has spent years hurting Harry’s friends and Harry himself. Draco is mouthing a horrible curse at Harry and Harry goes right back at him without thinking or knowing what it will do. As a Draconia that Harry cares about, he cares too much to use a spell he doesn’t understand on her. There is no way he could use an unknown spell on her. It goes against his core character concept as someone who instinctively defends others. And most of the bad interactions between Harry and Draconia would be different as well, and those drove many story elements in that book and moving forward. People who say that all of these various story beats in canon must be repeated in Malfoid stories to be true to the books do not understand how characters change stories. And the fact that characters change stories is why I do not agree with using the canon books as a straight jacket to keep all the Malfoid fan fiction stories on a leash.
There is also the little fact that most of the various fan fiction Malfoid stories show the Hogwarts students going to the Yule Ball as rather obvious 18 year olds. Considering they are treading on romance and the various laws on the books about depicting romance in conjunction with various age brackets, making them obvious 18 year olds is a wise decision on the creators’ parts.
The fact is that changing the character of Draco into Draconia is almost always going to incur major changes onto the story, and you should not expect to see all of the same scenes going the same way, or even occurring, just because they happened in the book or movie. Draconia Malfoy is a major change, and the story will change a great deal due to that infusion. And most creators I have seen take that idea and run with it.
Forge of War on Amazon
Angel Flight on Amazon
Angel Strike on Amazon
Angel War on Amazon
Wolfenheim Rising on Amazon
Wolfenheim Emergent on Amazon