I recently managed to watch Andor Season 2. The really short review is that it is much like most other Disney Star Wars stories in that there are a lot of miserable people doing miserable things to each other in a miserable universe. That said, Andor Season 2 is actually a good series.
If you like gritty series, then Andor is for you. Like Season 1, each story is 3 episodes long, so the best way to watch it is three episodes in one setting which is basically watching a movie. Season 2 has twelve episodes, so it is four movies worth of content, and it is very good.
It is a bridge between Andor Season 1, leading up to footsteps before the Rogue One movie, and it includes many new characters as well as bringing in actors and characters that show up in Rogue One. It was actually really fun to see many of these returning friends get some time to shine in Andor before they show up in the movie. Eight years later. It makes their appearance in Rogue One better. Yes, they did change the actor for one character, but the new actor did an amazing job. I’m beyond impressed with how he did it.
I then watched Rogue One and it is very much like Andor. Both good and bad. But I never liked the end, and I finally understand why. Andor never quits. He’s the guy that never stops doing one more thing until the lights go out. Most of the deaths in Rogue One are well earned and I have to say they are well done. But Andor isn’t the kind of guy to walk out onto a beach and watch the end come. Win or lose, impossible shot or not, he’s going to keep fighting for a way out until the very end and maybe a bit longer. I now dislike that scene even more than I did when I first saw the movie. It is a beautiful scene. Cinematography at its best. Whoever made it look that good deserves praise. But it doesn’t fit the character. I want to see Andor fight. Who knows… maybe somehow, he’ll survive to fight again… It wouldn’t be the first time a Star Wars character did that…